August 28 2017

Ontario Court Finds Insurance Company Must Pay Plaintiff’s Legal Costs on Full Indemnity Scale

Close up of rusty locked black gate bars with distant light seen through a tunnel

An Ontario Court recently released the Hoang v Personal Insurance Co. decision on legal costs against insurance companies that have wrongfully denied a claim. The Court noted that it is typical for courts to award legal costs to the successful party on a partial indemnity basis- that is in the range of 40-60% of one’s legal fees. But the Court here determined that the unique nature of an insurance policy suggests that successful plaintiff’s should be better compensated when fighting the wrongful denial of their insurance benefits:

 One purchases an insurance policy for coverage in the event of liability, and it is the premium payable under the policy that is the cost of that coverage. Insurance companies are by their nature constantly involved in litigation, and it would be unfair and burdensome to make their customers pay a premium plus legal fees in order to obtain the coverage they bought. The premium is presumed to reflect the insurance company’s risk. If it chooses to attempt to reduce that risk by engaging in litigation over its obligation to provide coverage it should be made to fully compensate the successful party if it loses.

 The Court thereby awarded the plaintiff full indemnity of their legal costs. As an office that assists many people through their struggle to access their insurance benefits, we certainly support the Court’s reasoning.


Image via Flickr: Denied by Jonathan Melhuish under Creative Commons Licence

Related News

Elsa Ascencio advocates for immigrant justice

Our articling student, Elsa Ascencio, was recently interviewed by New York Magazine about the Trump’s Administration’s decision to deport 200,000 Salvadorans from the United States. Nearly ...

Labour Day Parade 2015!

Jewitt McLuckie & Associates got a bird’s eye view of Ottawa’s Labour Day Parade 2015. Despite the scorching weather, there was a strong union presence, with enthusiastic marchers from CUPE, ...

Partner Samantha Lamb will speak at The Six-Minute Labour Lawyer 2016

Accommodation Overload: Are Unions Victims of Their Own Success? – On May 26th join Samantha Lamb to learn about issues for Labour Lawyers and Unions to be mindful of as workplaces reach their ...